Advanced search

The goalkeeper's fear of the dodgy decision

This week, Briefing is donning a replica shirt and pouring a lager, and is hoping, just for once, that the referee’s decisions aren’t going to cause any outbursts of rage. Fortunately, the football authorities are on the case.

FIFA has this weekend completed its technical analysis of proposed goalline technology with results expected to be debated by the International FA Board meeting at Celtic Manor on 5 March.

The study follows calls from some sections of the football community for a technological solution after recent contentious goalline decisions. Frank Lampard’s discounted ‘goal’ for England in the match against Germany during last year’s World Cup in South Africa intensified the debate.

Companies such as Adidas have already worked with FIFA to test a system that uses a microchip inside the ball. The practicalities of using such a system are likely to need some work, but if approved, similar technologies could be incorporated into football regulations.

Elsewhere, technology to improve our power grids is coming under the spotlight. On Thursday, Alexander Micallef from Malta University will be at a meeting organised by the IET at the Maltese resort of St Julians, discussing the evolution of the smart grid and ways in which we can secure our electricity supplies. His talk will be split into two parts; the first providing an overview of smart grids and the second focusing on micro grids.

More views on energy sustainability will be expressed at the ‘Energy from Waste’ event on Tuesday in Hammersmith. Mike Groom, a waste to energy advisor, will describe how domestic waste is converted into electrical power in mass burn waste to energy plants. Currently England produces in excess of 26 million tonnes of domestic waste each year. Of this 3.6 million tonnes are processed by incineration.

On Wednesday, two Russian cosmonauts will step outside the International Space Station to install and retrieve experiments on the Russian segment and deploy a small ham radio satellite. During the six hour mission, the cosmonauts will collect information on seismic forecasts, gamma splashes and optical radiation. The spacewalk can be viewed on NASA TV at 1.45am GMT.

Finally, BAE Systems will announce its full year preliminary results on Thursday. The aerospace and defence group announced in December that it would cut 1,400 jobs in the UK following the government’s defence review in October.

Readers' comments (8)

  • For all the efforts to microchip the ball, the technology needed to resolve most contentious decisions already exists and is in use at most major games. Namely, high quality, multi-angle live broadcast systems. Recourse to replays three or four times game would get to the bottom of most disputes. However, a microchipped ball is intriguing. More useful, though, would be a bionic, teflon coated Robin van Persie with a 5-year no injury guarantee.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • give the referee an iphone to carry on the shoulder. If we can see the replay within 2-3 seconds, he can as well.

    You cannot put the chip on the side of the ball: depending on where the chip is, it will be goal or not goal. You cannot put the chip floating in the middle of the ball, it will move about will all the shocks, kicks, etc...

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I look forward to the day that a technician tries to fix a ball fault while fans sing "you don't know what you're doing!"

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Ref Anon at 2:00 pm. The whole of the ball has to be over the line.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Chris D - if the sensor tells you where the centre of the ball is, and you know how big it is, then you know where the edge of the ball is. That would tell you whether the whole of the ball is over the line or not.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Lets make it easier. Make the goal face flat, put pressure sensors behind the wall. Make the goal half a ball smaller in all dimensions and put some steel angle around the side to prevent the system being hit from the edge.

    There would be no need for the ball to cross a line, no need for ball sensors at all.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Alternatively, the three match officials might try to keep a closer eye on proceedings during a match?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Perhaps, if it's so important, the FA or FIFA could look at the 1400 people facing redundancy at BAE Systems - there must be enough talent there to solve this trivial problem - they could pick up a whole development team and fund them for the cost of one Primadonna.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

Mandatory
Mandatory
Mandatory
Mandatory

My saved stories (Empty)

You have no saved stories

Save this article

Current Issue

The Engineer 14 May 2012

Poll

Local authorities in Cumbria and Kent are discussing the possibility of deep-level nuclear waste repositories, where waste will be sealed into underground vaults for thousands of years. What are your feelings about this method of disposing of high- and intermediate-level nuclear waste?

Previous Poll

Will the government's proposed large infrastructure projects be sufficient to lift Britain out of a second recession?

Click here to see the results and comment.