Advanced search

Engineering bodies call for better careers advice

Plans to change school careers advice could mean fewer young people consider a job in engineering, professional bodies have warned.

The government is creating an all-age independent careers service and, under a new education bill, all schools in England will have to provide careers advice from someone not directly on the school payroll.

A DfE spokesman told The Engineer: ‘The way that careers advice is currently delivered in schools isn’t working – over half of young people say it doesn’t meet their needs. That is why we are changing the system so that all schools have a duty to secure access to independent, impartial careers guidance for their pupils.’

But Education for Engineering (E4E), a group made up of 39 UK engineering organisations led by the Royal Academy of Engineering, said yesterday that this amounted to an end to schools’ duty to provide general careers education.

The group, which is chaired by BAE Systems chairman Dick Olver, said the plans could reduce the number of students aware of the opportunities of an engineering career.

‘Young people often do not make the connection between the mobile phones they use or the computer game consoles they play with on a daily basis and the engineers who created them,’ said Olver.

‘We need to better inform our children and young adults about the value of engineering and the exciting career opportunities an engineering background can afford.

‘Better careers education in schools and an improved professional independent careers service that advises young people of the many routes into engineering will improve this situation.
‘We must make sure that young people are fully informed about the exciting opportunities afforded by a career in engineering so that we will be able to meet the growing needs of our industries as we continue to re-balance the economy,’ Olver added.

E4E has recommended five requirements for improving the way careers education, advice and guidance is delivered and provided in schools and colleges:

  • a statutory entitlement for young people in England to receive lessons in careers education as part of personal, social and health education;
  • the need to demonstrate competence in the teaching of careers education as part of the professional standards for qualified teacher status;
  • the use of real-life science and engineering examples in lessons with careers awareness embedded in the curriculum
  • improved access to local and national labour-market information for schools and colleges, and closer links with local employers; and
  • specialist science, engineering and technology advisors in careers-advisory agencies — echoing the recommendations of the careers-profession taskforce.

Pressure group CaSE (Campaign for Science and Engineering) has also raised several issues with the education bill, including the lack of funding for careers advice.

‘We believe that one of the main reasons for lack of progression from school to science and engineering courses at university is poor careers advice,’ said CaSE director Imran Kahn in a letter to education secretary Michael Gove.

‘Inevitably this afflicts pupils from non-traditional backgrounds in poorer schools the most.

‘We suggest that a school’s performance in careers advice should be an explicit part of Ofsted inspections, as it is one of the most important elements of how schools serve pupils and parents alike.’

Kahn also said that the existing severe shortage of specialist science teachers could be exacerbated by the plans, which don’t include enough safeguards to ensure minimum standards in free schools and academies.

Readers' comments (3)

  • I don't believe that the five points suggested go far enough. The problem is deeper than this. There are very few teachers who have a good understanding and practical approach to Physics as well as Science. Most teachers never leave the the world of acedemia and hence have no life experinces outside education to give good advice to young people regarding engineering employment. I was a lecturer for a few years in a Polytechnic and noticed a decline in the number of students having passed Physics at high school. As an engineer this is a concern, as physics is the foundation block of engineering knowledge. It needs to be taught with a passion to instill interest to students and then demonstrate the applications of Physics leading on to the various disciplines of engineering.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I have looked into the careers advice online. Putting myself in the place of someone who was thinking about engineering, aged 14-18. The advice online is disjointed and incomplete. Looking at the IMeche, ChemE and the Civil engineers. The best site is the chemical engineers. I would have thought the engineering council should have some overall information with links to the various instrutustions.

    Examples and case studies are key. Also information like where can you work? Who can you work for, hours of work, do you work inside out outside? Future employment prospects. Rates of pay. These should overcome the prejudice that engineering is difficult, dangerous and dirty and poorly paid.
    The information on the government website is not complete. How about a “what do engineers do?” video on you tube that would make it easy for teachers/ careers advisers to get the message across. Also a page on facebook/wikipedia would help.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • My daughter is in the process of choosing which A levels to study prior to going to University in a couple of years. She is a very good mathematician and scientist. She does not know where to go down the life science or engineering road. She enjoys “problem solving” and wants to do something that marks a difference! Back to the point she is finding it very difficult to find out what it is really like to be an engineer we went to an open evening at Airbus yesterday but this was aimed at craft apprenticeships with little real information. Unless companies and the scientific communities produce good quantity information student like by daughter will be lost to science and engineering.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say


My saved stories (Empty)

You have no saved stories

Save this article