Saturday, 25 October 2014
Advanced search

Back on track: Electric motorcycles race for innovation

The regulation-light world of electric motorbike racing is reaffirming the link between motorsport and innovation

It was an unseasonably warm early spring day on the southern tip of the Isle of Man. Seagulls were wheeling overhead; the sun was glinting off the Irish Sea and an American motorcycle racer was making some very strange noises.

’When you’re riding a gasoline bike, it’s all RRRrrrrrrRRRR change down! Rrrrrrrrr change down, change down! Rrrrwoooo round the corner and slam the gas on, RRRRRRRRR!!!’ Mark Miller said, leaning forward across the table and miming his changing grip on a pair of phantom handlebars. ’But when you’re on an electric bike, it’s just eeeeeeeeeeee… all the way around. It’s what I’d imagine being on a magic carpet would be like. It’s like flying. I’ve never experienced anything like it.’

Miller, a cheerful, lanky Californian, is one of very few people to have experienced an electric motorcycle at speed; he’s also among the fastest. Last year, he was the winner of the TTZero race, a time-trial event for electric bikes around the Isle of Man’s famous Tourist Trophy mountain course 38 miles of narrow, twisting, bumpy public roads threading their way through fields and villages, and between hedges and stone walls.

Riding a motorcycle developed and built by Portland, Oregon-based motorsport specialist MotoCzysz, Miller finished the course more than two minutes ahead of his nearest competitor, clocking up maximum speeds of about 140mph and achieving an average of slightly more than 96mph. For comparison, conventional petrol-fuelled bikes top out at slightly more than 200mph and average up to 136mph. And the gap is narrowing.

Mark Miller riding to victory at last year’s TTZero

Mark Miller riding to victory at last year’s TTZero

So why are electric motorbikes not becoming a common sight on our roads in the way that electric and hybrid-electric cars are? With the TTZero and the circuit-based electric-bike racing series TTxGP demonstrating that the technology is reliable enough for a high-speed duty, why are similar machines not tackling the supposedly far less arduous duty of country roads and motorways?

Miller provided an important insight. ’Riding a gasoline bike, you throw it around the course. You go as fast as you can, depending on the road; on a straight, you open the throttle right up. But on an electric bike, it’s very different.’

The biggest bugbear of the electric-vehicle sector, range anxiety, makes its presence felt even more when the vehicle has two wheels. ’You have to think all the time about how much charge you’ve got,’ Miller explained. ’I had to watch the charge meter very carefully and I was constantly balancing the speed I was doing against the reading on that meter. It’s really important to do that, otherwise you’ll run out of charge part way around the course and you won’t finish.’

The issue here is very simple: motorbikes are smaller than cars and very sensitive to weight. The energy density of the power source is crucial. As any automotive engineer knows, liquid-hydrocarbon fuels have a very high energy density. The comparatively small fuel tank of a large motorbike will take the vehicle a long distance (or a relatively short distance very fast). But for an electric bike, you have to rely on batteries and they can only manage a fraction of the energy density of petrol or diesel. Even though electric motors are far smaller, lighter and more efficient than the huge steel lumps of internal combustion engine that conventional bikes lug around, cramming enough batteries onto a bike frame to give it the performance needed for a race or for a decent journey on conventional roads is a taxing engineering problem.

Many of the machines on the TTxGP grid and TTZero starting line are based on existing motorcycles, stripped down to the basic components, rebuilt with electric motors and batteries, and adapted to take account of the differences in loading and handling that electric power brings. This, most participants agree, is a time when motorsport is truly the R&D department of an automotive sector. There are many differences between the various bikes. Many have multiple motors to give the required power; some have regenerative braking systems to feed charge back into the batteries. There are marked differences between control systems, software and firmware. All, at the moment, are direct drive, with no gearing system which, according to Miller, is the biggest difference in the riding experience.

’You control the bike entirely through the throttle and the brake,’ he said. ’It’s weird, we’re used to braking the bike with the engine, changing down through the gears as you approach the corner. But with these bikes you don’t have that option.’

Miller’s ride, the MotoCzysz E1pc, is one of the few designed from scratch rather than based on a donor bike. ’Ultimately, it’s a huge compromise to take an existing bike,’ explained MotoCzysz director Michael Czysz. ’It is an advantage in a sense, because you’ve got reasonable geometry and a reasonably light bike for great strength, but there has to be a compromise. We want to look beyond the gasoline motorcycle and build the best electric bike we can, and the best way to do that is from the ground up.’

The MotoCzysz racing company produces bikes for the MotoGP superbike championship and Czysz is himself an avid motorbiker and racer, both on conventional and electric bikes. ’Apart from my family, the biggest thing in my life is motorcycles,’ he said. Czysz’s great grandparents were bikers; his grandfather was a legendary racing motorbike tuner and rider (Czysz bikes have been racing since the 1940s); and his father is one of the race mechanics for the E1pc. ’I think the one thing that separates us from other commercial companies developing electric bikes is that we understand the motorcycle,’ Czysz said. ’Motorcycles have certain traits that draw people to them. We’re interested not in moving away from that, but expanding on it.’

The biggest bugbear of the EV sector, range anxiety, is even more prevalent when the vehicle has two wheels

Apart from a few parts, everything on the E1pc is designed specifically for the bike. Its distinctive look showcases the technology two rows of five batteries take the place of a conventional bike’s engine, resembling a ribcage. The batteries, containing lithium-polymer cells and each storing 12.5kWh, plug directly into the frame. ’Last year, everyone was talking about making the races two-lap, with longer laps and mandatory pitstops, so making the batteries hot-swappable was a big priority for me,’ Czysz said. ’On this year’s bike, the batteries will still be swappable but it’ll take about half an hour rather than two minutes.’ That change will allow Czysz to make fewer compromises with the construction and saves weight.

Hot wheels: the E1pc’s batteries are hot-swappable

Hot wheels: the E1pc’s batteries are hot-swappable

The E1pc runs on a single motor, again custom built but using a commercial rotor and stator. The inverter-controller and oil-cooling system are developed by Czysz. Last year’s model has a continuous power output of 60kW and torque of 600-850Nm, operating at 4,300rpm. It weighs 59kg and measures 490 x 330 x 370mm. ’This year’s model will be almost twice as powerful. It’ll develop the equivalent of 200bhp and will be about 20kg lighter than last year’s 238kg,’ said Czysz.

Dubbed the D1g1tal Dr1ve, the motor is likely to be the big money spinner from E1pc, rather than the bike itself. Even Czysz sees electric biking as more of a motorsport pursuit than a commercial one.

’This may surprise you, but I don’t believe there is any significant market for electric bikes at present and I say that as a fourth-generation motorcyclist. Look at the type of gasoline motorcycle you can currently purchase; its reliability and cost frankly, electric motorbikes just don’t come close.’

So why do it? For Miller, it’s for the magic carpet ride; for Czysz, it’s motorsport at its purest. ’I’m completely addicted to racing,’ he said.

“This may surprise you, but I don’t believe there’s a significant market for electric bikes at present”

Michael Czysz, MotoCzysz

’What we’re doing right now feels like I think it did when privateers had a huge influence on racing. It’s the most open rules of any motor racing there is. If you have an idea, you have more opportunity to showcase it in electric racing than even in MotoGP.’

Despite this, Czysz said that the E1pc would be fully capable as a commercial product. ’Mark does 37 miles at 100mph on a full charge,’ he explained. ’The amount of air pressure he sees and that the bike has to overcome is probably about three times as much as someone averaging half that speed, which you would on a normal motorcycle journey. We’ve probably got a solid 150-mile range and that’s not bad at all. But a battery pack is so expensive, you’d have trouble justifying our bike over a simple Japanese motorcycle that costs a fraction of the price.’

Side view of the E1pc

At speed on salt: The E1pc goes through its paces on Bonneville Salt Flats

What it does do, however, is prove the robustness of the electric drive train. The area of the rear tyre of a motorbike in contact with the road is the size of the palm of your hand, Czysz said. ’We can control 200bhp and that huge torque through that contact patch better than we can with an internal combustion engine, and we can fit it all into a motorcycle with 95 per cent efficiency. That’s a good testament to the technology.

You could not show our ideas on a better platform than a motorcycle on the Isle of Man TT course.’ Just to prove it, MotoCzysz is about to deliver its first contracts for the D1g1talDr1ve one for a ’very substantial vehicle’ for the US Department of Defense, the other for a commuter vehicle. Neither are bikes, Czysz said; but without the bike, neither would exist.

Ride along with Mark Miller on the MotoCzysz E1pc at last year's ZeroTT

back story - recycled cycles

An engineering team from Imperial College London is using donor bikes for its entry to the TTZero race

Several of the TTZero teams are from university departments, underlining the R&D status of electric bikes. For Andrew O’Dell Vnukov, leader of the team at London’s Imperial College, the project represents another strand in the green-motorsport sector.

’Imperial already has several motorsport projects, such as Racing Green Endurance, which took an electric car down the Pan-American Highway, and Formula Student, which develops single-seat circuit-racing cars,’ Vnukov said.

The Imperial team, from the mechanical engineering department, is taking the donor bike route, starting off with a Suzuki Hayabusa superbike. ’We started off by looking at the size of battery we would need and looked for a bike with a frame that would be suitable. The Hayabusa was the best fit for that,’ Vnukov explained.

The bike has two 32kW motors mounted on the swing arm, with direct drive to the rear wheel. The batteries are at the front.

’Packaging is the main issue we’re facing; just getting all of them onto the bike is a massive challenge, even with a bike as big as the Hayabusa,’ Vnukov said. ’We’ve designed a new battery frame and mount for the motors, and the bodywork.’

Last year, the team failed to get the bike to the Isle of Man; this year, it is hoping to complete testing and fine-tuning, and get to the starting line. ’And next year, we plan to build a bike from scratch.’

Related videos


Readers' comments (9)

  • I am a biker but this bike makes me want to try one out. The battery cost is noted as high, just now, but it may drop. Cells look to be slided in from either side, assuming top and/or bottom connections. People hear me coming on a bike, so I may end up using the horn a lot more as these are almost silent. Like the idea, great innovations coming out of it, the motor development will have applications in other areas. Good luck with this!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • While Michael Czysz was refreshingly honest about how far electric bikes have to go before they're better than petrol driven ones, his cost/benefit analysis applies to where exactly? There is a major price differential between petrol in the US and in the UK, and there are several countries in Europe where the price is even higher than in Britain. In the next 5 - 10 years the price of oil and increasing anxiety about peak oil will continue to play into the hands of engineers developing electric/hybrid vehicles.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I definitely agree with first two comments. I like the idea and yes I am a biker too, I further think governments should really think about electrical vehicles as a way to boost our economy and do something to promote it ! All the money not spent on petrol could be used to relaunch consumption.
    Imagine the savings companies could make by switching their "petrol fleet" to electrical vehicles, an average of 50€ every two weeks, per car ....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I like the idea of electric bikes and it's going to be a must in the next 10years with the increase in oil and fuel prices, however as a biker the biggest thing to me is the loss of the noise, it would be a bit fake to add a speaker with some engine notes but i dont think i could cope riding the TT course on something that sounds like a prius!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am a biker and engineer, we have to face facts that petrol and associated plastic materials will run out and the sooner we put significant effort into these developments and infrastructure the better. The creativity and design that has gone into this electric bike has my utmost admiration and I wish them all the best for success.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Speaking as a regular visitor to the TT, I looked forward to the inaugural electric race (TTX as it was called) in 2009 and I was amazed at the difference that 12 months had made for the 2010 race. Performance has increased considerably. The effort to create such a marvellous machine can only bring benefits for us bike riders. I for one would jump at the chance to have a go on one.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hi there all, as a biker and a vast interest in renewable energy I am wondering if there would be a good use for the drive train from the electric bike (that I two would love to ride) in to a larger bike with a small petrol/diesel or hydrogen power system to recharge the batterys or run the motors them self?
    There has been a very good development in the bike and if this was used with a engine how would the distance covered compare?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I'm a biker and engineer and I work on projects involving electric bikes but I still agree with Czysz.
    Electric vehicular projects pay the bills but personnally I'm convinced it's all a big technological dead end. I've yet to see any viable solutions to the 2 remaining problems for battery vehicles; ie cradle to grave environmental impact and long distance journeys.
    Until these 2 problems are addressed electrical vehicles will remain a whimsical dream.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • O Pearson makes a good point about lifecycle environmental impact.

    Are we replacing one scarcity issue (oil) with another (Lithium)?

    Whether you replace fossil fuel cars with biodiesel, hydrogen, electric or hybrids, there are still scarcity issues.

    The problem is: these shiny new eco-friendly technologies tend to get latched onto by policymakers without fully assessing their impact, biodiesel & bioethanol was a classic example. Did no-one (except maybe George Monbiot) predict the dire effect of the 5% biofuel target for european forecourt fuels would have on food prices?

    As fuel prices continue to rise what we are seeing are rapid rises in rail travel and cycling in the UK. 'Top Gear' types will disagree, but the future role of trains and cycles is not to be underestimated.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

Mandatory
Mandatory
Mandatory
Mandatory

My saved stories (Empty)

You have no saved stories

Save this article