Advanced search

Hydrogen embrittlement could lead to failure of fuel-cell cars

Fuel-cell cars may suffer from sudden failure of parts and components because of the little-known effect hydrogen can have on the metals used in vehicle engineering.

This is the concern of researchers at the Fraunhofer Institute for Mechanics of Materials in Freiburg, Germany, where specialist teams are studying a phenomena known as hydrogen-induced embrittlement.

Hydrogen is viewed as an eventual alternative to fossil fuels for transport, but the chemical element has an unusual way of making common vehicle metals such as steel, aluminium and magnesium brittle.

It has been shown that hydrogen can infiltrate metal lattice through corrosion or during chromium plating of car parts. This infiltration may also occur during welding, milling or pressing. The result is always the same: the material may tear or break without warning.

In a fuel-cell vehicle this could have detrimental effects on everything from the fuel tank and parts of the fuel cell to ordinary components such as ball bearings.

Nicholas Winzer, a researcher at the Fraunhofer Institute for Mechanics of Materials, said problems associated with hydrogen-induced embrittlement have been published since the early 1800s, but the issue still has no clear resolution. 

‘It’s not terribly well understood,’ he said. ‘It’s something that is very interesting for scientists because it’s complicated and quite challenging to figure out. It tends to be, for engineers, something that’s not really thought of until it becomes a problem.’

The Fraunhofer researchers are attempting to visualise, on an atomic scale, what happens to metal components when exposed to hydrogen. With this information, Winzer said that it could one day be possible to develop a software program that will help engineers design materials and components that mitigate hydrogen-induced embrittlement.

‘The easiest thing you can do is make sure the hydrogen doesn’t get into the material and you can do that by using different types of coatings that protect the material,’ he said. ‘But once the hydrogen is actually inside the material it can move around quickly and cause damage in different ways. The challenge is to stop the hydrogen from moving around.’

Winzer said that it could be theoretically possible to design ‘hydrogen traps’ in a material’s microstructure.

‘It could be some defect, it could be some little particle of impurity inside the material that causes that site to attract hydrogen and hold it,’ he said, adding that, while this could help slow material deterioration, there is no ‘cure all’ for hydrogen-induced embrittlement. 

Their experiments will mimic the experience components will undergo in a vehicle by combining the forces of temperature, mechanical stress and hydrogen. As metal samples are continuously heated up, the researchers will apply stresses to the material with special tensile test equipment that permits simultaneous mechanical loading and infiltration with hydrogen. The team will then determine the resistance of the material.

The researchers will use the results from the laboratory tests for computer simulation and calculate the hydrogen embrittlement in the metals. They will enlist Finite Element Method simulation to investigate the interaction between hydrogen and metal, both on an atomic and a macroscopic scale.

It is hoped that this will allow them to determine not only the most suitable materials for hydrogen, but also the best manufacturing process to create components.

Readers' comments (14)

  • Don't throw away the plastic padding and fibeglass just yet

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Why is this a problem if the hydrogen is in a fuel cell?

    Or is this about using hydrogen as fuel for an IC engine? This does not seem sensible - IC engines are less efficient than a fuel cell plus electric motors, particularly for start-stop operation in towns.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Is it little-known, or have we been studying it since the 1800s? It might have been better to say, "poorly understood" rather than "little-known" as it's well known among the engineering community of which this magazine is a part.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hybrid microcircuit designers have been using "hydrogen getters", like flypaper for hydrogen, for years....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • What effect if any do carbon fiber products have?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The question of hydrogen embrittlement is raised from time to time at hydrogen fuel cell conferences, presentations and the like, particularly where the audience is being introduced to hydrogen technology for the first time. The answer given is usually as follows.

    Yes, hydrogen embrittlement is a well-known issue, and if care were not taken with the design and, in particular, with the choice of materials, then it would certainly cause difficulties. However designers are aware of it, and do take care, and therefore it is not seen as presenting a significant problem.

    It is then pointed out that hydrogen has been used very widely throughout industry for at least a hundred years. In that time the gas and chemical industries have gained much experience in how to handle it safely, and provided the established design practices are carefully followed, there should be no problems.

    This of course applies to the whole fuel system that comes into contact with hydrogen, obviously the fuel cell or ICE, but also the storage tank, valves, pipes, joints, etc., as well as the supply infrastructure.

    None of which is say that the Fraunhofer research will not lead to a better understanding of this important topic, which is as relevant to the manufacture of fertilizer, petrochemicals, margarine, metals, semiconductors and electricity (cryogenic cooling), as fuel cells.

    Brian, hydrogen embrittlement has nothing whatsoever to do the relative efficiencies or attractiveness of FCs versus ICEs.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Thanks Brian Pollard. IC engines are less efficient in so many ways including management of combustion, transmission, pollution, heat generation and so on. We need to drive electrical motors using cells- energy from some natural resources. See no merit in keeping an IC engine as the power house.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hydrogen embrittlement is a well-known issue especially with pipelines transporting the gas to refineries. Prototype cars, buses and other vehicles have logged over a million miles in real world road testing without the hydrogen embrittlement problem. So, why would this be a problem now?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I thought if you added 0.5 % hydrogen to the fuel then the the air to fuel ratio increases at least twice which makes the engine more efficient. Thus then whole fuel system and internal part of engine would have to cater for the embrittlement.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Please read this article entitled "Great Solution to "Hydrogen Embrittlement Problem - Open the flood gates of fuel cell real commercialization ? -

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 per page | 20 per page

Have your say


My saved stories (Empty)

You have no saved stories

Save this article