Friday, 31 October 2014
Advanced search

How much is an engineer worth?

As always happens when yet another report emerges warning of a UK engineering skills shortage, the initial response from vocal readers of The Engineer has been to decry the level of pay that engineers receive in this country.

As one reader pointed out, the 15 per cent wage premium mentioned in the report for those who’ve studied for years to gain an engineering qualification doesn’t seem a lot. However, it’s not the whole picture, so I thought I’d draw out some extra points from the Royal Academy of Engineering-commisioned study.

According to the Office for National Statistics’ Labour Force Survey of 163,218 people aged 16–64 in England & Wales between 2004 and 2010, looking at those who had STEM qualifications and those who worked in SET jobs, there was:

  • a 19% wage premium for STEM overall;
  • a 10% premium for science occupations;
  • a 33% premium for technology occupations;
  • a 15% premium for engineering occupations;
  • but hybrid science/engineering occupations do not attract a premium.

This implies that if you work in an engineering job you are likely to earn an average of 15 per cent more than the average person in the UK (but not 15 per cent more than minimum wage, as one reader suggested).

The Labour Force Survey for the first quarter of 2011 found median wage for engineering professionals to be £29,700. The ONS median full time salary in the UK in 2011 was £26,244 – which makes that 15 per cent figure look about right.

These engineering jobs will include technicians and medium-skilled workers. However, if we look at engineering graduate salaries and compare them to those of people with only two A Levels, we see a bigger premium.

Data from the Department of Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) showed that an engineering graduate in 2009 was likely to earn 32 per cent more than someone with two A Levels. This was also higher than the average graduate premium, which was only 27 per cent above the salary of A Level holders.

The Academy’s report also found that engineers’ salaries rose sharply as they got older, suggesting employers put an even bigger premium on experience than they do on qualifications.

This can also be seen in a June 2010 survey by ERS of registered engineers and technicians, which found the median wage of incorporated engineers was £41,345, and the median wage of chartered engineers to be £52,609.

The other point to remember how are perceptions of typical earnings in the UK are skewed by the vast amounts earned by some company directors and those in banking – a sector often accused of draining talent from the engineering graduate pool by offering salaries that manufacturing firms just can’t compete with.

Some politicians, newspaper journalists and professionals would consider £50,000, £60,000 or even £100,000 to be a middle class salary. And that’s certainly a lot less than the million-pound bonuses available in the City. But if the median salary is £26,000, then there are an awful lot of people out there for whom £50,000 would be a modest fortune.

Engineers who work hard by studying for years, gain desirable and useful skills, and help change the world for the better deserve a substantial reward. Unfortunately, engineering doesn’t always produce the kind of short-term profits that facilitate the bonuses and commissions seen in financial services.

Research and development, product design and building manufacturing facilities require substantial investment and long-term strategy, whereas moving imaginary pots of money around on a computer – while often socially useless or even damaging – can create money almost from thin air.

That’s not to say there isn’t a problem with engineering salaries, or that it wouldn’t be worth engineering firms looking again at their own payrolls if they want to encourage more young people into the sector. But engineers’ earnings are always going to be limited to some degree by the money available.


Readers' comments (68)

  • If anyone is interested in knowing what an accredited engineer can earn in Alberta, Canada, refer to the salary survey at www.apegga.org

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Thanks for the link above. Extremely interesting. Average salary for an intern is $50k (£30k), a graduate $68k (£41.6k), and a senior engineer $212k (£130k).

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I work for a large multi national Engineering firm based in Glasgow. I'm slightly staggered by some of the comments here. I have a physics background and have moved into the world of engineering 3 years ago. In that time I have become chartered and have seen my salary increase significantly. I'm working on challenging projects and an surrounded by a very professional workforce. I'm now proud to call myself an Engineer and would like to see British Engineering restored to its historical heights.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • At the guy with 20 years engineering experience and teaching at a college, if you were actually any good you'd still be in industry raking in the big bux. Lets take me for example, 30 years old, 8 years experience, IEng, contracting in the Oil & Gas sector, onshore office based, clearing over 2k per week AFTER tax. Dont tell people to stay clear of engineering when clearly the money is great if youre any good. Work hard and aim for the correct sector and you're laughing all the way to the bank!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I got placed in a company in UK, which will pay me 7500 gbp+ allowances+acco. So , I just want to know is it a good salary.please suggest I am from India and planning to reallocate there.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • If you're content with being just an engineer, and engineering solutions time after time, then you will never go beyond £35k in the UK.

    The increase in salary comes with a good appreciation of the business side and having the ability to develop client relationships - not always attributes that come naturally to the typical engineer.

    I have BEng, MSc & CEng. I don't shout about this - it's not on my email footer or even my business card. I insist on being judged on my work as a well-rounded engineer and ambitious future business leader in the sector.

    My qualifications along with my 7 years experience are on my CV however, and have assisted in enabling me to negotiate a salary of £50k at the age of 30. I plan to double this within 10 years through becoming a business owner in some capacity - in the UK, in engineering.

    In summary, engineering will always be my bread and butter. My career is nothing without this. But this alone will not be enough to allow me to excel into a highly paid role in the industry. This requires a greater appreciation for business and relationships as a whole. I'd anticipate this philosophy could be similarly applied to many industries.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I lay here in bed reading through these comments after applying to university for a course in industrial design which offers me free membership into the institute of design engineering, I look forward to this and even to becoming a design engineer but it seems people like us with the dreams that we have and ambitions to change the world aren't appreciated through pay, has anyone got any advice for what I should do ? I'm only 19, no experience... Applying to uni this year in Brunel - uxbridge London, thanks all, every word will be valuable

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The career will be fulfilling and you will get to work on amazing things. Unfortunately in the UK we don't get paid a great deal. The average age of an engineer is creeping up close to the retirement age, eventually they will retire and salaries will have to rise.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It was announced today that there is an issue with engineers leaving the armed forces and recruitment. Salary was identified as an issue that needs to be looked at. This is just the start of the issue that will go through the entire industry.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I have just read the Jan issue of Materials World (IOM3 institute magazine). After 3 years 70% and 50% of male and female engineers respectively have left the sector to work in a related sector.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Ummm, some of these comments have actually got me feeling quite good about my position. I have been in the electronics industry for nearly 10 years. I started working for a company that design and manufacture medical equipment whilst undergoing 5 years of university which included an HNC and a degree.
    I finished with a 3rd class BEng in electronics (i had fun at uni), and then returned to work for a further 2 years earning £16,000 per annum. This was a bit of a p**** take. I left to work at ABB (flow metering sector) in the Gloucestershire area as an Electronics hardware engineer, I started on £25,000 and 2 years later went up to £30,000. I am 28 years old. I feel good about this amount of money and am sure that my salary will increase as I gain in experience and move through future job roles. I expect to earn about £40,000 in no more than 10 years time. (Even with the standard 2.5% yearly pay increase, I will be on £50,000 a year by the time I am 50, this may not be very much at that time, but I consider this to be an absolute minimum).

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Anonymous. Is that in today's money? If not it is barely above the intended rate of inflation, ~2%. Well behind recent inflation figures we have seen (apart from the most recent).

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Science and engineering salaries are better in China at 20-40K pounds for an engineer. Need we say any more?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I thought I was on a modest salary of £50k after 12 years working in Rail with BEng MSc CEng MICE qualifications.

    Perhaps my view has been skewed by the fact former colleagues have left for the oil & gas sector whom are being paid considerably more, i.e. earning more than the Prime Minister in some cases.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I did a degree in electronics and a PhD, I have reach Senior status and now found that I've reached the ceiling in terms of pay and that no matter how much I improve or get better I will never get paid any more unless I leave the UK and go to another country. The huge other professions which earn so much money in the UK make it impossible to lead a good quality of life no matter how brilliant at engineering you might be.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • One of the problems in the UK is a plumber can drive around with the word ‘Engineer’ written on the side of his van, I would not have the audacity to call myself a plumber!! If in our office our photocopier breaks down, you call the helpline and they respond with “we will get our Engineer out ASAP” Engineer? Really? Do these people hold a HND or BEng minimum? I doubt it.
    It belittles our profession, a profession which relies on an in depth knowledge of Maths, Physics and the Sciences – yes the hard subjects! The trick is to specialise, I can earn £35/hour as a contractor or upwards of £50K permanent as a powertrain calibration engineer in the automotive sector. Always in demand too. In my experience component engineers, manufacturing engineers and program engineers generally earn less and are less in demand. But yes foreign shores value Engineers far more that this misdirected, city biased country.
    The brand ‘British Engineering’ if there ever was such a thing, was ruined by the unions in the sixties and seventies. Poor quality, unreliability etc…were synonymous with anything built British. On the contrary look at present day Germany, an economy built on its engineering prowess. We have the housing market and suits in cities.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I have a basic University degree and have worked in Engineering design now for 22 years. My typical gross earnings when in the UK are about 210,000 GBP gross per year. Comparible earnings in most countries outside of the UK. I don't know anyone who Is well established and experienced and respected who earns less than about 150,000 GBP gross, apart from staff people. Currently have not been working for nearly four months now, because the job market has dried up, and agents contact me about jobs paying a NET of around 9000 GBP per month, which I don't want to work for.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I'm 30 and on ~£50k (includes £3k bonus) in integrated circuit design. To be honest, I feel hard done by as the work is mentally intensive and my friends in other easier jobs earn more! I think the only money to be made in engineering in the UK is in oil gas (want high pay? Go into a high paying industry - what was I thinking!). I'm tired of the whole thing already and wish I'd done something else. The only thing I feel I can do is try to move into oil & gas, but unfortunately I don't think electronics engineers even earn that much there (it's mostly structural, mechanical & petrochem engineers that earn there).


    In summary... the wages are rubbish considering the difficulty of the work. Don't do it!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 per page | 20 per page | 50 per page |

Have your say

Mandatory
Mandatory
Mandatory
Mandatory

My saved stories (Empty)

You have no saved stories

Save this article